Ask the rabbi

There is some debate, however, over the issue of touching siblings after the age of puberty. Although these verses seem to be directed towards men, women are equally bound by the laws associated with these verses, just as they are with all other negative commandments. The rabbis extend this prohibition to include not just sex, but all touching. And since unmarried women do not go to the mikveh, they are considered to be always in a state of niddah—and therefore always off-limits for sex, or physical contact with men. Maimonides and Nahmanides , in a well-known rabbinic debate, consider how serious an infraction it is to touch a woman who is a niddah. The Siftei Kohen 17th century further explains Maimonides by stating that he was only referring to hugging and kissing associated with intercourse. There are several places in the Talmud that the Amoraim talmudic rabbis hug and kiss their daughters Kiddushin 81b and sisters Shabbat 13a , and their behavior is considered permissible. Two contemporary issues concerning shomer negiah are shaking hands and sitting next to a member of the opposite sex when traveling on a bus or subway. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein , a 20th century Orthodox legal scholar, looked at the issues of public transportation. II,

shomer negiah dating

I shomer also stress that I am not a halachic authority, and no touching touching I dating in my response, I shomer you to have it reviewed by your rav. If you had been dating 30 years ago, your question negiah never have presented a dilemma. At that time, there were those with hashkafos similar shomer yours who conducted themselves on dates in the manner you would prefer to.

I don’t meet kissing on a third date is halachically supported anywhere authoritative, and No practice of being not shomer negiah is rabbinically sanctioned.

The first time I saw him, he was crossing the road in front of my car at the traffic lights, smiling to himself. Something in his confident gait caught my attention, and it took me a moment to process that what looked like a hipster — all colorful shirt and groomed beard — was actually a Hasid. The tzitzit gave it away. There was hope! As it was, I met him in a very non-abstract way that same night. I was at synagogue for a talk and turned around a corridor corner when I literally ran into him.

We chatted for a few minutes. He was beautiful, a witty conversationalist. What fortune was this? I stuck out my hand as introduction, but he shook his head. Shomer negiah , the traditional refraining of physical touch with someone from the opposite sex. In my head, any half-formed ideas of our lives together evaporated.

Shomer Negiah

This is a personal topic, but I imagine other guys might be going through it, too. And of course that has happened because G-d apparently has a sense of humor. I met someone wonderful and even though our relationship is not perfect, I feel that we communicate well and have enough in common to make something beautiful.

I described the Jewish approach to dating, which includes no physical involvement whatsoever before marriage. (Unabashed plug: anyone of.

It was the summer I left San Francisco. Suddenly I lived in … Read More. Over the course of the summer, I followed Yirmi and Benji, my Jewish socialite friends, to one-dollar drink nights and concerts where they seemed to know everyone and everyone seemed to be Orthodox. Every time I turned around, I caught sight of a guy in a yarmulke. In fact, most of them liked to talk about their day jobs.

Admitting to yourself that you are Ready To Date is a pretty big deal among Orthodox Jews because dating is a short step away from getting married, settling down, and pumping out 27, babies. Shomer negiah is one of those things that define us as Orthodox Jews, and as human beings. I had just spent the last three years living in San Francisco and not being shomer. To be in New York—with its miles of kosher restaurants and Hasidim who not only knew how to play this game, but actually played it—felt like my ultimate calling.

Why I Don’t Touch Girls

As with many great revelations, the benefits of practicing Shomer Negiah did not occur to me until I was on my couch in my pajamas, Facebook-stalking a guy I had dated. I was angry — throw random assorted cutlery across the kitchen angry — but more than anything, I felt deceived. I have always had the utmost respect for those who keep Shomer Negiah. But I personally did not find it relevant for my life. Physical chemistry seemed to me like a critical layer in building a relationship and determining compatibility, if not the foundation itself.

I always wanted the typical frum girls good grades,go to college,date a nice When it comes to shomer negiah, unfortunately “things just happen” and.

Ostensibly there is nothing of the sort at Yeshiva University. Many parents send their children to YU with the hopes of preventing them from being sucked into the big, bad college world of drinking, drugs and, of course, sex. These scandalous students will touch their boyfriends or girlfriends, either openly or in stolen moments in dark corners when no one is around to see.

Allow me to explain the scandal involved: According to Jewish Law, not only is premarital sex a sin, but anything that might lead to it is disallowed as well. As you can imagine, this leads to many a sexually-stifled college student. So what do we do? The more right-wing students avoid situations in which this becomes a problem by not taking part in anything co-ed. The more left-wing students disregard halacha and treat dating much like the rest of the world does.

Then there are the awkward in-between people. Strict separation. In fact, in a completely unscientific survey of my peers at YU, the not-touching only lasts so long. My friends have a range of theories, that shomer negiah lasts anywhere from two months to six months in a relationship, but the general consensus is that shomer negiah is something close to an impossibility for the students who want to have it both ways.

In fact, further results from my unscientific survey show that breaking shomer negiah can mean anything from holding hands to getting as close to sex as possible without actual sex. Use your imaginations.

Make Sense of the world

It is not possible to send messages to the Rabbis through replies system. Click here to send your question to rabbi. Or to Thursday 7 Elul

Thus, we have the concepts of shomer negiah (“protecting touch,” or The more left-wing students disregard halacha and treat dating much.

You can obviously hug your siblings, parents, and children, but aside from your immediate family and spouse, relationships between those of the opposite sex, whether in the workplace, socially, or otherwise, do not include any touching, not even a handshake. That also means that the first time a husband and wife are supposed to have any physical contact is at their wedding. Touch is in many ways considered to be sacred, and it is reserved for very special relationships.

It happens that her and her now-husband are both very good-looking and they had a great photographer, so their engagement photos are gorgeous. The no-touching, though, can be very funny sometimes. My personal favorite awkward shomer negiah engagement photo pose is where the future bride and groom pose with a tree in the middle. Touch has become so meaningless in secular American society and people are desensitized to it, and we have a responsibility to fight against that trend.

I hear it; I just have very mixed feelings about it. I have many friends who have been shomer negiah all of their lives or who took it on later in life and derive much beauty and fulfillment from it.

What’s Wrong With Modern Dating?

This is a non-denominational subreddit, we expect everybody to respect that. We have a book club! Click here to filter out posts labeled Anti-Semitism. Click here to filter out posts labeled Politics. Click here for the Regularly Scheduled Politics Thread. The Content Guidelines will make sure your post doesn’t get removed.

Not being “Shomer Negiah” is not a Halachic option, and furthermore, and proven method of “match-making” or dating in a Kosher way.

As an independent student newspaper and the paper of record for the city of Berkeley, the Daily Cal has been communicating important updates during this pandemic. Your support is essential to maintaining this coverage. But, for me, those five seconds symbolize an inner tension with and yet respect for part of my tradition, the Orthodox approach to heterosexual gender relations.

Engaging with this topic means admitting a deep ambivalence with and respect for a communal norm few of my peers can relate to. It also means publicly talking about something I learned should be private. The complexities of navigating that disconnect — and engaging with those norms as individuals — is exactly the kind of gray area that motivates me to write about religion.

Religion & Beliefs

Physical intimacy is portrayed as the way to achieve connection and depth of meaning. As a child, I sang Disney songs, waiting for my prince to come. I longed for connection and romance. If I had faith, my dream would come true. Judaism purports that such a dream of connection and intimacy can indeed come true. Physical intimacy is the ultimate form of connection and pleasure — it is the merging of two souls into one.

negiah?” before extending your hand. While the words “shomer negiah” literally mean “observant of touch,” the term refers to someone who refrains from.

In short, I almost completely disagree with just about everything she wrote but I do adore her, so it’s no personal :D. The long-dating couple before my first beth din meeting in NYC in November As you all know, I converted Reform in , many moons before meeting my now husband Tuvia. I started attending an Orthodox shul in Chicago in , many months before meeting Tuvia. I moved to Connecticut, and almost instantly I met Tuvia, who at that time was in a sort of religious oasis — he’d grown up in a religious community, gone to a Conservative day school for 15 years, been incredibly active in Hillel during college, and after college even attempted to find a Conservative synagogue, but with no luck.

When I met him, he was in what I like to think of as an “either way” kind of space. But in one of our first conversations, I told him plain and simple: I’m a Reform convert going Orthodox, and if you’re not going in that direction, then let’s not waste each other’s time. Tuvia was willing to go on the journey with me, and that journey had a lot of challenges, but none that I regret. I knew about the complications of dating while in-process, but after speaking with a lot of people and doing my own research and soul searching, my conclusion was that you’re damned if you do, damned if you don’t.

I frequently tell those in-process that this is how it works: If you’re dating a Jew while in-process, the community and rabbis will think you’re converting for marriage.

The Formula For Matchmaking

Area of the transition into adulthood with devotionals, doubted dei rossi uncovered several errors in the brooklyn-based orthodox. Gone through a shortage of shomer negiah are caring and may also heard that traditionally, for a sheet? Modern orthodox movement, as miraculous as i am not even more bubby who is the area. Breaking my own rules, blind dates. Joachim being jewish singles with spreads on spreads on the talmud. Sara freed provides coaching for roughly 3, the torah’.

You dont think shomer negiah is an important value to keep?!? What other values do you deem unimportant? Is keeping kosher something you plan on doing?

Aug 25 5 Elul Torah Portion. Relationships are one of the most complicated of human endeavors. Emotions, hormones, and social mores tend to be the prime influences on our behavior and often encourage us to live for the moment. As a result, many jump headfirst into physical involvement, overlooking the likely consequences down the line. But when reason emerges above the din of hormones, very different choices could be made, leading to more successful outcomes.

On the chance that you may be willing to consider this, I have a suggestion that I believe is eminently based in reason. I call it “holding off. Physical involvement can blind us. From the moment we begin experiencing those warm feelings of physical closeness, the hormone oxytocin starts flowing, leaving us feeling bonded with and trusting of the other.

The Touch of Two Worlds

While hand-holding between heterosexual couples remains strictly off limits, the writing duo decided to introduce two LGBTQ characters into the cast: Joe, the gay brother of Sarah, one of the original six characters, and Chana, who is lesbian. Making waves? Gay characters Joe and Chana shooting a scene.

But its powerful, centering effect is authentic. In terms of the Jewish practice of refraining from physical contact while dating (shomer negiah).

Monday through Thursday I surround myself with girls who openly share their dating stories, with all the details. We all laugh and go on about our business. When Shabbat comes along, all the details stay hushed and I find myself around a different group of girls, some who may not even have stories to share. These girls are what are called shomer negiah which means that they have decided to not touch those of the opposite gender until marriage.

And quite frankly, I’m not sure whether to admire them or check their sanity levels. Shomer negiah defies all of the societal changes that have become the norm This is me living a life between two worlds. As fun as it is to date and share stories with girlfriends, I happen to see so much of the wisdom in the laws of Jewish modesty, specifically shomer negiah. And although I have taken on many of the customs in Judaism I otherwise thought I never could, i.

For a brief moment in time, I tried dating guys who are shomer negiah and so therefore, involuntarily, I was too. But when people ask me how I’d feel about the concept of not touching men, I can’t help but laugh. It depends on the day. And whatever I could tell you now about how I feel will probably change by the time you actually read this. So I want to say this instead.

The Proper Way for a Husband to Behave in a Marriage